Difference between revisions of "Animal Antics by Neil Griffiths and Janette Louden"
(Created page with "{{infobox |title=Animal Antics |author=Neil Griffiths and Janette Louden |reviewer=Keith Dudhnath |genre=For Sharing |rating=3 |buy=No |borrow=Maybe |isbn=978-1905434961 |pape...") |
|||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
|summary=An interesting idea, that will help get young kids in the mood for the Olympics. However, the text isn't appropriately pitched at picture book fans, and so the idea doesn't achieve its full potential. | |summary=An interesting idea, that will help get young kids in the mood for the Olympics. However, the text isn't appropriately pitched at picture book fans, and so the idea doesn't achieve its full potential. | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | + | It's the run-up to World Sport Week. Thanks to a rules challenge (presumably by a lawyer bird), animals are to be admitted for the first time. With much flapping of wings and clattering of hooves, the animals proceed to turn this Olympics-esque event into a whitewash for the non-human competitors. | |
''Animal Antics'' has a strong core idea, and is a great way to give little kids a taste of the Olympic spirit. However, it doesn't always hit the right notes. It's very definitely overwritten, both in terms of volume of text and the vocabulary used. There aren't - with good reason - many picture books that use the phrase ''organisational issues'' as a punchline. | ''Animal Antics'' has a strong core idea, and is a great way to give little kids a taste of the Olympic spirit. However, it doesn't always hit the right notes. It's very definitely overwritten, both in terms of volume of text and the vocabulary used. There aren't - with good reason - many picture books that use the phrase ''organisational issues'' as a punchline. | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
Janette Louden's illustrations are perfectly pleasant, but given that the core idea is laden with such fun, one wonders how much more zingy it could have been if she'd really let her hair down. The potential is there to have really made the little 'uns giggle. | Janette Louden's illustrations are perfectly pleasant, but given that the core idea is laden with such fun, one wonders how much more zingy it could have been if she'd really let her hair down. The potential is there to have really made the little 'uns giggle. | ||
| − | ''Animal Antics'' isn't far off being a broad recommendation. It would certainly benefit from punchier text, but the premise will please some little ones enough, especially if they've been (quite rightly) bombarded with sport all summer. | + | ''Animal Antics'' isn't far off being a broad recommendation. It would certainly benefit from punchier text, but the premise will please some little ones enough, especially if they've been (quite rightly) bombarded with sport all summer. |
For other books featuring exciting animal antics, take a look at [[Zebedee's Zoo by Giles Milton and Katharine McEwen]] or [[A Very Strange Creature by Ronda Armitage and Layn Marlow]]. | For other books featuring exciting animal antics, take a look at [[Zebedee's Zoo by Giles Milton and Katharine McEwen]] or [[A Very Strange Creature by Ronda Armitage and Layn Marlow]]. | ||
Revision as of 20:19, 18 June 2012
| Animal Antics by Neil Griffiths and Janette Louden | |
|
| |
| Category: For Sharing | |
| |
Reviewer: Keith Dudhnath
 | |
| Summary: An interesting idea, that will help get young kids in the mood for the Olympics. However, the text isn't appropriately pitched at picture book fans, and so the idea doesn't achieve its full potential. | |
| Buy? No | Borrow? Maybe |
| Pages: 36 | Date: March 2012 |
| Publisher: Red Robin Books | |
| External links: Author's website | |
| ISBN: 978-1905434961 | |
|
Share on: | |
|
| |
It's the run-up to World Sport Week. Thanks to a rules challenge (presumably by a lawyer bird), animals are to be admitted for the first time. With much flapping of wings and clattering of hooves, the animals proceed to turn this Olympics-esque event into a whitewash for the non-human competitors.
Animal Antics has a strong core idea, and is a great way to give little kids a taste of the Olympic spirit. However, it doesn't always hit the right notes. It's very definitely overwritten, both in terms of volume of text and the vocabulary used. There aren't - with good reason - many picture books that use the phrase organisational issues as a punchline.
The quirkiness of the story would have leant itself well to rhymes, which might keep things contained. Having chosen straight prose instead, unfortunately, it's too loose and sprawling to really click with young book fans. That said, some bright and newly confident readers might well enjoy having it read to them as a treat.
Janette Louden's illustrations are perfectly pleasant, but given that the core idea is laden with such fun, one wonders how much more zingy it could have been if she'd really let her hair down. The potential is there to have really made the little 'uns giggle.
Animal Antics isn't far off being a broad recommendation. It would certainly benefit from punchier text, but the premise will please some little ones enough, especially if they've been (quite rightly) bombarded with sport all summer.
For other books featuring exciting animal antics, take a look at Zebedee's Zoo by Giles Milton and Katharine McEwen or A Very Strange Creature by Ronda Armitage and Layn Marlow.
Please share on: 
Facebook, 
Twitter and
Instagram
You can read more book reviews or buy Animal Antics by Neil Griffiths and Janette Louden at Amazon.co.uk Amazon currently charges £2.99 for standard delivery for orders under £20, over which delivery is free.
Template:Waterstonestext
Comments
Like to comment on this review?
Just send us an email and we'll put the best up on the site.
