Open main menu

Changes

no edit summary
At times ''The Story of English'' can be charming and surprisingly quirky. There are some great anecdotes: did you know, for example, that King James had a particularly large tongue? Or that the first Poet Laureates were paid in wine? But Piercy can’t identify which facts or stories are really interesting and pause to spend more time on them. In fact, he doesn’t seem to have any faith in his primary material. He keeps panickily trying to cram in more and more anecdotes until the reader sinks, exhausted, under a relentless hail of slightly pointless information.
''The Story of English'' is based on a lot of fascinating history. Unfortunately, not only does it not have enough space to do its material justice, it wastes precious pages trying to cram in too much disparate information. Describing the journey of the English language is a laudable idea, but this slender volume lacks both the space and the focus to properly carry it out. The result is as odd and mixed as the English language itself. I’m sad to admit it, but this book, while well-intentioned, is just a muddled series of factoids too nerdy for an average reader but too basic for an English linguist. Yes, I enjoyed parts of it, but its wasted potential ultimately left me frustrated.
Word nerds may get more out of [[The Etymologicon by Mark Forsyth]]