132,858
edits
Changes
From TheBookbag
Jump to navigationJump to searchAll The Truth That's In Me by Julie Berry (view source)
Revision as of 11:18, 7 July 2013
, 11:18, 7 July 2013Created page with "{{infobox |title=All The Truth That's In Me |author=Julie Berry |reviewer=Robert James |genre=Teens |rating=3.5 |buy=Maybe |borrow=Yes |isbn=978-0670786152 |pages=288 |publish..."
{{infobox
|title=All The Truth That's In Me
|author=Julie Berry
|reviewer=Robert James
|genre=Teens
|rating=3.5
|buy=Maybe
|borrow=Yes
|isbn=978-0670786152
|pages=288
|publisher=Viking Children's Books
|date=September 2013
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>0670786152</amazonuk>
|amazonus=<amazonus>0670786152</amazonus>
|website=http://www.julieberrybooks.com/
|video=
|summary=While it doesn't always work and can feel gimmicky at times, there's enough strong points to this story of a voiceless girl to make it worth while taking a look at.
}}
Four years ago, Judith and another girl disappeared. Two years ago, Judith came back alone, and unable to speak. Shunned by most of the people in her close-knit community, can she find her voice to save those around her, and herself?
I wasn't quite sure what to expect with this one, having seen only a little bit of the publicity for it, but it was intriguing enough to pick up. I found Judith's narrative voice difficult enough to get hooked by that I nearly put it down very quickly, to be honest. It's told in the form of a letter to childhood friend and crush Lucas, and the second-person narrative is unusual and, at first, jarring. However, in a similar vein to [[How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff]], when I kept going I eventually got used to the voice and drawn in by it. That's not to say it's as good as Rosoff's classic - but it's an interesting style which is worth persisting with, and makes the book stand out as something really different from the majority of recent fiction.
That difference, to be honest, is both the book's strength and its weakness. Yes, it stands out from the crowd, but I couldn't help feeling at times that the style was more of an attempt to stand out rather than one which suited the story that well. Having said that, after persisting, I found it an engaging read - but would I have carried on with it, rather than putting it down early on, if I wasn't reviewing it? I'm not sure. I found the characters reasonably interesting, the villains truly evil, and the plot was unpredictable. All good things, of course - but opposed to them, there's a couple of characters whose motivations I had real problems understanding, and I found the central idea not to stand up to too much scrutiny. I think the idea of a girl rendered literally voiceless in a society which is already pretty suffocating towards girls of her age is superb. I'm not altogether convinced it's explained that well - even unable to speak or write, it seemed difficult to believe that two years would pass without her making more of an effort to find another way to communicate some important information.
Am I overthinking it? Perhaps I am. There's a lot to like here in many ways, and it's unusual and striking enough to have a decent chance of doing well in awards. I just think there's slightly too many flaws to make it that much of a recommendation.
Certainly worth borrowing, at the very least, and I'd encourage anyone else who struggles with the first fifty pages or so to stick with it. Mild recommendation, and I'll be interested in seeing more from Julie Berry.
I think fans of the style here will definitely love [[How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff]].
{{amazontext|amazon=0670786152}}
{{commenthead}}
|title=All The Truth That's In Me
|author=Julie Berry
|reviewer=Robert James
|genre=Teens
|rating=3.5
|buy=Maybe
|borrow=Yes
|isbn=978-0670786152
|pages=288
|publisher=Viking Children's Books
|date=September 2013
|amazonuk=<amazonuk>0670786152</amazonuk>
|amazonus=<amazonus>0670786152</amazonus>
|website=http://www.julieberrybooks.com/
|video=
|summary=While it doesn't always work and can feel gimmicky at times, there's enough strong points to this story of a voiceless girl to make it worth while taking a look at.
}}
Four years ago, Judith and another girl disappeared. Two years ago, Judith came back alone, and unable to speak. Shunned by most of the people in her close-knit community, can she find her voice to save those around her, and herself?
I wasn't quite sure what to expect with this one, having seen only a little bit of the publicity for it, but it was intriguing enough to pick up. I found Judith's narrative voice difficult enough to get hooked by that I nearly put it down very quickly, to be honest. It's told in the form of a letter to childhood friend and crush Lucas, and the second-person narrative is unusual and, at first, jarring. However, in a similar vein to [[How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff]], when I kept going I eventually got used to the voice and drawn in by it. That's not to say it's as good as Rosoff's classic - but it's an interesting style which is worth persisting with, and makes the book stand out as something really different from the majority of recent fiction.
That difference, to be honest, is both the book's strength and its weakness. Yes, it stands out from the crowd, but I couldn't help feeling at times that the style was more of an attempt to stand out rather than one which suited the story that well. Having said that, after persisting, I found it an engaging read - but would I have carried on with it, rather than putting it down early on, if I wasn't reviewing it? I'm not sure. I found the characters reasonably interesting, the villains truly evil, and the plot was unpredictable. All good things, of course - but opposed to them, there's a couple of characters whose motivations I had real problems understanding, and I found the central idea not to stand up to too much scrutiny. I think the idea of a girl rendered literally voiceless in a society which is already pretty suffocating towards girls of her age is superb. I'm not altogether convinced it's explained that well - even unable to speak or write, it seemed difficult to believe that two years would pass without her making more of an effort to find another way to communicate some important information.
Am I overthinking it? Perhaps I am. There's a lot to like here in many ways, and it's unusual and striking enough to have a decent chance of doing well in awards. I just think there's slightly too many flaws to make it that much of a recommendation.
Certainly worth borrowing, at the very least, and I'd encourage anyone else who struggles with the first fifty pages or so to stick with it. Mild recommendation, and I'll be interested in seeing more from Julie Berry.
I think fans of the style here will definitely love [[How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff]].
{{amazontext|amazon=0670786152}}
{{commenthead}}
