Difference between revisions of "The Potter's Hand by A N Wilson"
| (3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | {{ | + | {{infobox1 |
|title=The Potter's Hand | |title=The Potter's Hand | ||
|sort=Potter's Hand | |sort=Potter's Hand | ||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
|borrow=Yes | |borrow=Yes | ||
|isbn=9781848879515 | |isbn=9781848879515 | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
|pages=416 | |pages=416 | ||
|publisher=Atlantic Books | |publisher=Atlantic Books | ||
|date=September 2012 | |date=September 2012 | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
|summary=Excellent historic fiction based around the family of Josiah Wedgwood in the period between the US revolution and the French revolution. An interesting man in a fascinating period makes for a compelling read. | |summary=Excellent historic fiction based around the family of Josiah Wedgwood in the period between the US revolution and the French revolution. An interesting man in a fascinating period makes for a compelling read. | ||
| + | |cover=1848879512 | ||
| + | |aznuk=1848879512 | ||
| + | |aznus=B008QO905S | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | The man of clay that A N Wilson throws onto his storytelling wheel in ''The Potter's Hand'' is the great Josiah Wedgwood, but this is much more than a historic telling of his life. Indeed, Josiah already has a thriving business at the start of the book. What Wilson does particularly impressively is to put Wedgwood's achievement and works into the context of the politics and social philosophy of the times, sandwiched between the two great revolutions in America and France. In order to do this, Wilson has to play slightly loose with artistic licence by altering dates and | + | The man of clay that A N Wilson throws onto his storytelling wheel in ''The Potter's Hand'' is the great Josiah Wedgwood, but this is much more than a historic telling of his life. Indeed, Josiah already has a thriving business at the start of the book. What Wilson does particularly impressively is to put Wedgwood's achievement and works into the context of the politics and social philosophy of the times, sandwiched between the two great revolutions in America and France. In order to do this, Wilson has to play slightly loose with artistic licence by altering dates and timelines a bit, but it works well. He also balances the real historic figures with several key figures of his own invention and where the historic figures don't quite fit with his narrative, he alters their ages and invents 'facts' to the benefit of the fictional narrative. |
Wilson's approach is a broad one, following a number of sub-plots throughout the book. Indeed, poor old Josiah often seems to float around on the edge of his own story for much of the book as Wilson concentrates on his nephew, Tom Byerley, who would run the family business after the period of this novel, and the entirely fictional characters of Caleb and Heffie Bowers and Blue Squirrel, a Cherokee girl that Tom meets while seeking to negotiate the supply of American kaolin to meet the order for the Catherine the Great. Also central to the book is Wedgwood's oldest daughter, Sukey, whose later children included Charles Darwin. | Wilson's approach is a broad one, following a number of sub-plots throughout the book. Indeed, poor old Josiah often seems to float around on the edge of his own story for much of the book as Wilson concentrates on his nephew, Tom Byerley, who would run the family business after the period of this novel, and the entirely fictional characters of Caleb and Heffie Bowers and Blue Squirrel, a Cherokee girl that Tom meets while seeking to negotiate the supply of American kaolin to meet the order for the Catherine the Great. Also central to the book is Wedgwood's oldest daughter, Sukey, whose later children included Charles Darwin. | ||
| Line 28: | Line 23: | ||
The result is a novel of ideas ranging from colonialism, slavery, the welfare of workers, class, religious belief, industrialisation and, with Charles Darwin's grandfather, the lecherous old Dr Darwin as the family doctor, early thoughts on evolution. | The result is a novel of ideas ranging from colonialism, slavery, the welfare of workers, class, religious belief, industrialisation and, with Charles Darwin's grandfather, the lecherous old Dr Darwin as the family doctor, early thoughts on evolution. | ||
| − | This impressive and thoughtful breadth of approach does come at a cost though. I never really felt that I got to know Josiah as a character throughout the book. Wilson doesn't really explore the depth of his genius or innovation to any great extent. Sure we are told but never really shown. Also the various | + | This impressive and thoughtful breadth of approach does come at a cost though. I never really felt that I got to know Josiah as a character throughout the book. Wilson doesn't really explore the depth of his genius or innovation to any great extent. Sure we are told but never really shown. Also, the various subplots can lay frustratingly latent for long periods of the book, particularly the fascinating storyline of the fictional Blue Squirrel. Her story alone would have made for a compelling novel but here gets a little lost. There are also some troubling conflicts between some of the ideas. Blue Squirrel is, in her own way, touched with the skill and one might even say genius of Josiah which seems to underplay his role and for all the hugely interesting early thoughts on evolution, the undoubtedly great Josiah is the result of high levels of family inter-marriage which seems to run counter to the survival of the fittest ideas that are emerging. |
| − | At other times though the conflicts themselves are fascinating. There's irony that the Frog Service produced for Catherine the Great depicted rural idealistic scenes of Britain at a time when the producer is doing much to destroy this with the beginnings of the industrial revolution. | + | At other times though the conflicts themselves are fascinating. There's an irony that the Frog Service produced for Catherine the Great depicted rural idealistic scenes of Britain at a time when the producer is doing much to destroy this with the beginnings of the industrial revolution. |
| − | There's also a slight tendency towards famous name dropping. To a large extent this is inevitable as Josiah knew and interacted with a wide range of people who we know of today - Stubbs, Coleridge, Watt, to name but a few. However some of these seem to be slightly forced into the narrative in ways that don't add a great deal to the central story. | + | There's also a slight tendency towards famous name dropping. To a large extent this is inevitable as Josiah knew and interacted with a wide range of people who we know of today - Stubbs, Coleridge, Watt, to name but a few. However, some of these seem to be slightly forced into the narrative in ways that don't add a great deal to the central story. |
The quality of the writing is superb though and Josiah Wedgwood was a fascinating man at a pivotal historic period and Wilson brings these two together well. You get a strong sense of the personal struggles of family life. It's a wonder that anyone achieved anything given the doses of laudanum that they were all taking for various ailments. If you are looking for a broad stroke historic novel that addresses the great ideas of the time, then this will be very much your cup of tea, served in a doubtless exquisite Wedgwood tea service. I would have found it more compelling though if there had been a stronger central core to the book, be that Blue Squirrel, Sukey or even the old man himself. | The quality of the writing is superb though and Josiah Wedgwood was a fascinating man at a pivotal historic period and Wilson brings these two together well. You get a strong sense of the personal struggles of family life. It's a wonder that anyone achieved anything given the doses of laudanum that they were all taking for various ailments. If you are looking for a broad stroke historic novel that addresses the great ideas of the time, then this will be very much your cup of tea, served in a doubtless exquisite Wedgwood tea service. I would have found it more compelling though if there had been a stronger central core to the book, be that Blue Squirrel, Sukey or even the old man himself. | ||
| Line 38: | Line 33: | ||
Our thanks to the lovely people at Atlantic Books for sending us this book. | Our thanks to the lovely people at Atlantic Books for sending us this book. | ||
| − | It's been a strong year for historic fiction. Well worth checking out in this genre are [[Merivel: A Man of His Time by Rose Tremain]] and [[Bring up the Bodies by Hilary Mantel]]. If the tantalizing glimpse of Charles Darwin in this book has | + | It's been a strong year for historic fiction. Well worth checking out in this genre are [[Merivel: A Man of His Time by Rose Tremain]] and [[Bring up the Bodies by Hilary Mantel]]. If the tantalizing glimpse of Charles Darwin in this book has piqued your interest in his life then [[Darwin's Sacred Cause: Race, Slavery and the Quest for Human Origins by Adrian Desmond and James Moore]] is an excellent next step. We also appreciated [[Aftershocks by A N Wilson]] and [[The Four Gospels with introductions by A N Wilson, Nick Cave, Richard Holloway and Blake Morrison]]. |
| − | {{amazontext|amazon=1848879512}} {{ | + | {{amazontext|amazon=1848879512}} |
| + | {{amazonUStext|amazon=B008QO905S}} | ||
{{commenthead}} | {{commenthead}} | ||
[[Category:Literary Fiction]] | [[Category:Literary Fiction]] | ||
Latest revision as of 11:42, 2 October 2020
| The Potter's Hand by A N Wilson | |
|
| |
| Category: Historical Fiction | |
| |
Reviewer: Robin Leggett
 | |
| Summary: Excellent historic fiction based around the family of Josiah Wedgwood in the period between the US revolution and the French revolution. An interesting man in a fascinating period makes for a compelling read. | |
| Buy? Yes | Borrow? Yes |
| Pages: 416 | Date: September 2012 |
| Publisher: Atlantic Books | |
| ISBN: 9781848879515 | |
|
Share on: | |
|
| |
The man of clay that A N Wilson throws onto his storytelling wheel in The Potter's Hand is the great Josiah Wedgwood, but this is much more than a historic telling of his life. Indeed, Josiah already has a thriving business at the start of the book. What Wilson does particularly impressively is to put Wedgwood's achievement and works into the context of the politics and social philosophy of the times, sandwiched between the two great revolutions in America and France. In order to do this, Wilson has to play slightly loose with artistic licence by altering dates and timelines a bit, but it works well. He also balances the real historic figures with several key figures of his own invention and where the historic figures don't quite fit with his narrative, he alters their ages and invents 'facts' to the benefit of the fictional narrative.
Wilson's approach is a broad one, following a number of sub-plots throughout the book. Indeed, poor old Josiah often seems to float around on the edge of his own story for much of the book as Wilson concentrates on his nephew, Tom Byerley, who would run the family business after the period of this novel, and the entirely fictional characters of Caleb and Heffie Bowers and Blue Squirrel, a Cherokee girl that Tom meets while seeking to negotiate the supply of American kaolin to meet the order for the Catherine the Great. Also central to the book is Wedgwood's oldest daughter, Sukey, whose later children included Charles Darwin.
The result is a novel of ideas ranging from colonialism, slavery, the welfare of workers, class, religious belief, industrialisation and, with Charles Darwin's grandfather, the lecherous old Dr Darwin as the family doctor, early thoughts on evolution.
This impressive and thoughtful breadth of approach does come at a cost though. I never really felt that I got to know Josiah as a character throughout the book. Wilson doesn't really explore the depth of his genius or innovation to any great extent. Sure we are told but never really shown. Also, the various subplots can lay frustratingly latent for long periods of the book, particularly the fascinating storyline of the fictional Blue Squirrel. Her story alone would have made for a compelling novel but here gets a little lost. There are also some troubling conflicts between some of the ideas. Blue Squirrel is, in her own way, touched with the skill and one might even say genius of Josiah which seems to underplay his role and for all the hugely interesting early thoughts on evolution, the undoubtedly great Josiah is the result of high levels of family inter-marriage which seems to run counter to the survival of the fittest ideas that are emerging.
At other times though the conflicts themselves are fascinating. There's an irony that the Frog Service produced for Catherine the Great depicted rural idealistic scenes of Britain at a time when the producer is doing much to destroy this with the beginnings of the industrial revolution.
There's also a slight tendency towards famous name dropping. To a large extent this is inevitable as Josiah knew and interacted with a wide range of people who we know of today - Stubbs, Coleridge, Watt, to name but a few. However, some of these seem to be slightly forced into the narrative in ways that don't add a great deal to the central story.
The quality of the writing is superb though and Josiah Wedgwood was a fascinating man at a pivotal historic period and Wilson brings these two together well. You get a strong sense of the personal struggles of family life. It's a wonder that anyone achieved anything given the doses of laudanum that they were all taking for various ailments. If you are looking for a broad stroke historic novel that addresses the great ideas of the time, then this will be very much your cup of tea, served in a doubtless exquisite Wedgwood tea service. I would have found it more compelling though if there had been a stronger central core to the book, be that Blue Squirrel, Sukey or even the old man himself.
Our thanks to the lovely people at Atlantic Books for sending us this book.
It's been a strong year for historic fiction. Well worth checking out in this genre are Merivel: A Man of His Time by Rose Tremain and Bring up the Bodies by Hilary Mantel. If the tantalizing glimpse of Charles Darwin in this book has piqued your interest in his life then Darwin's Sacred Cause: Race, Slavery and the Quest for Human Origins by Adrian Desmond and James Moore is an excellent next step. We also appreciated Aftershocks by A N Wilson and The Four Gospels with introductions by A N Wilson, Nick Cave, Richard Holloway and Blake Morrison.
Please share on: 
Facebook, 
Twitter and
Instagram
You can read more book reviews or buy The Potter's Hand by A N Wilson at Amazon.co.uk Amazon currently charges £2.99 for standard delivery for orders under £20, over which delivery is free.
You can read more book reviews or buy The Potter's Hand by A N Wilson at Amazon.com.
Comments
Like to comment on this review?
Just send us an email and we'll put the best up on the site.
